Problems with water in Google Earth 3D

As Google continues rolling out 3D imagery one outstanding problem that they don’t seem to have been able to resolve is what to do about water. The cause of the problem is quite simple – water usually doesn’t stand still. Google’s 3D imagery is generated via a process called stereophotogrammetry, which involves taking multiple images from different angles and then working out the 3D shape of the landscape. However, if something moves or changes between images then the technique fails. Google has improved the way it deals with moving vehicles, as we noted when looking at New York, but they don’t yet seem to have found a way to deal with water.


What should be a relatively calm river, turns into a dangerous canyon.

The problem mostly occurs along rivers and shorelines. Away from the shore, Google turns off the 3D altogether and instead we can observe interesting ghosting effects where multiple images of boats and ships are merged together.


Here we can see four images were captured in close succession.They must be captured from slightly different angles, although it is hard to tell. Remember that both the camera and the boat are moving.


In some cases it is difficult to count how many images there are.


For some reason sports fields often also have a problem. It has something to do with the large area of uniform colour.

Google puts extra effort into particular buildings and bridges, often with fairly detailed modelling and excellent results. We suggest they consider also spending a bit of time flattening out the water, as it would greatly improve the imagery.

To see the locations featured in this post in Google Earth, download this KML file. You can, however, find examples of the problem almost anywhere where there is 3D and water.

About Timothy Whitehead

Timothy has been using Google Earth since 2004 when it was still called Keyhole before it was renamed Google Earth in 2005 and has been a huge fan ever since. He is a programmer working for Red Wing Aerobatx and lives in Cape Town, South Africa.






PLEASE NOTE: Google Earth Blog is no longer writing regular posts. As a result, we are not accepting new comments or questions about Google Earth. If you have a question, use the official Google Earth and Maps Forums or the Google Earth Community Forums.

Comments

  1. musammut says:

    So one day earth wont have water!

  2. Sebastien says:

    Deep learning will help one day, for instance by recognizing a stadium and knowing it is always flat. Classical algorithms don’t work well indeed. The Seene app for instance, the best app so far for personal photogrammetry, isn’t also able to deal with great area of uniform color. Our brain does a better job by knowing a lot of geometry about lots of stuff. The need to utilize the deep learning there, as they do with the facial recognition in Street view.

  3. collin237 says:

    In the first image, note that two of the boats have been used for the iconic ceiling lights that appear inside tunnels.



PLEASE NOTE: Google Earth Blog is no longer writing regular posts. As a result, we are not accepting new comments or questions about Google Earth. If you have a question, use the official Google Earth and Maps Forums or the Google Earth Community Forums.